Skip to main content

What Are the Benefits of Leasing a Car? Learn the Pros and Cons.

When choosing a new vehicle, decisions often turn to whether to buy new, buy used or lease. In any situation, it pays to do proper research before entering into any financial agreement. As you choose the best route for you, determine what type of vehicle you’d like to drive, what you’ll be using it for, and for what time frame. As with any important decision, it helps to create a list of pros and cons. We’ve put one together for you, complete with other relevant information about the process.

Pros of leasing a car

Lower monthly payments

A monthly lease payment may be less than a loan payment on the same car. A lease payment accounts for the depreciation value of the car, rather than the total value of the car when it’s purchased.

Fewer costly repairs

Generally, leased cars are newer and in better condition. Cars in their prime years are less likely to need costly repairs. Typically, leased cars are covered by the manufacturer’s warranty and include free oil changes and other, covered repairs.

A safer vehicle

Leasing a car allows you to drive a nicer vehicle than you may be able to afford if you bought a car outright or got a car loan. As a result, you may get a car with better safety features.

Tax advantages

Self-employed? You may be eligible for tax benefits on a leased car. But if you also use the vehicle for personal reasons, you may need to prorate the deduction based on a percentage of use.

Easy returns

When your lease ends, you can just return the car to the dealership. You don’t have to worry about finding out the car’s trade-in value or finding a buyer.

Cons of leasing a car

Higher overall costs

Over time, leasing a car costs more than buying one, especially if you lease multiple cars in a row and have monthly payments for years. In contrast, if you take out a loan to buy a car, you’ll eventually pay it off.

Wear-and-tear fees

It’s important to return a leased car in pristine condition—or you may get stuck with a costly wear-and-tear fee. Kids, pets or just a few dings from parking lots can rack up wear-and-tear fees.

Limited mileage

Most lease contracts limit the number of miles you’re allowed to drive, typically 12,000 per year. Be aware of “low mileage” leases, which only allow 10,000 miles per year. If you go over, fees can range from 10 to 20 cents per mile.

Early termination fees

Many car leases have early termination fees or other penalties if you need to cancel early. Sometimes, these charges can cost as much as the entire lease.

Costly parts

You’ll still have to pay for some maintenance, like new tires. Depending on your vehicle, this may be expensive, especially if it’s a nicer vehicle that has high-end wheels.

Steps to leasing a car

Learn about leasing

Get on the internet and research to decide if it’s right for you.

Think long term

Consider keeping the car up to three years so you have it while the manufacturer’s warranty protects the car.

Estimate monthly payments

Look for a car lease calculator online to estimate a monthly payment for your area. Make sure leasing a car fits into your budget.

Look for vehicle deals

It’s time to shop around. Look online or visit local dealerships to find a car that suits your needs. 

Test drive

Visit dealerships to test drive vehicles in person. See the car up close, ask questions, and get a feel for how it drives.

Negotiate a lease

Once you find a vehicle you like, discuss a lease’s terms with a salesperson. Ask questions and see if you can negotiate a lower price. 

Sign the paperwork

When you’ve settled on the right vehicle and contract, sign your lease and drive. Make sure to read all of the paperwork and keep copies for your records.

Cost of leasing vs. buying

Here’s a breakdown of the average total out-of-pocket costs over six years (the average length of time an American keeps a car)

  • Leasing a car: $38,880*
  • Buying a new car: $40,184
  • Buying a used car: $27,167

* An average lease lasts three years. To accurately compare to the average six-year loan/ownership of a vehicle, this lease estimate includes a second three-year lease.

What to do when your lease ends

At the end of your lease’s term, you have three options:

Option 1: Lease another car

If leasing is still a good option for you, return your car to the dealership and lease another model. You’ll still go through the inspection, pay a disposition fee (a fee at the end of the lease to prepare the car for the next buyer that can cost between $300 and $400) and wear-and-tear fees, but the dealership may offer incentives to lease again.

Option 2: Return the car without a replacement

You can return a leased car without getting a new one. Maybe you want to take some time before buying a new car. Or maybe it was a second car, and you’ve decided to downsize. You’ll still go through the inspection and pay any necessary fees.

Option 3: Buy your leased car

If you fell in love with your leased car, you may be able to buy it. It’s called “leasing to own.” Your lease should state the value of the car when it’s time to return it, called “residual value.” Beware: The actual value may be less than the residual value, so it’s recommended that you shop around first.
 

Steps to return a leased car

  • Prepare for an inspection. If you see minor dents or paint chips that you can repair on your own, now’s the time. Do anything possible to prevent additional wear-and-tear fees.
  • Get a second inspection. If you get an initial inspection and then decide to make repairs, it’s OK to get a second inspection. It may help you save in fees.
  • Pick a dealership. Usually, you can return a leased car to any dealership that’s the same brand. But you may have the easiest experience returning it to the same dealership where you initially leased the car.
  • Give back everything. Clean out your car to ensure you have all your belongings. Gather all the leased items, including a second set of keys, floor mats or spare tires. Otherwise, you may get charged for keeping these items.

 

How leasing impacts auto insurance

Whether you lease or buy a vehicle, you’re likely legally required to purchase auto insurance. If you lease a car, though, you may have to pay for more coverage. Leasing companies often want to ensure their cars are fully protected—which means requiring the lessor to buy more insurance protection. Discuss your car insurance requirements when negotiating your lease. Understanding more of the process benefits you in the long run.

You can also call your auto insurance company at any time to learn about your policy details. It’s possible they’ll help you negotiate a lower price or share details about your current coverage. Remember, your insurer is there to advocate for you.

Want to learn more about Amica auto insurance?

Get a quote online today

or call 833-513-3881

Sources
Should I Lease or Buy a Car: A Comprehensive Guide, CNN, 2024
Leasing vs. Buying a New Car, Consumer Reports, 2024
Mistakes to Avoid When Leasing a Car, Bankrate, 2024
Should You Buy a New, Certified Pre-Owned, or Used Car?, Consumer Reports, 2024
Returning a Lease Car: What to Expect, Kelley Blue Book, 2023
The tax benefits of leasing vs. buying a car for your business, Bankrate, 2024
Should you buy a new or used car? Here’s how to decide, CNBC, 2024

 

Your Policy, Policy Declarations or Amended Declarations in effect on the date of loss is the primary source of reference for your coverage, coverage limits and deductible amounts.

This inclusion of non-Amica companies, products, services or statement herein (“Third-Party Content”) is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement by Amica Insurance. Policies, views, opinions or positions of Third-Party Content expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the policies, views, opinions or positions of Amica Insurance. Amica Insurance makes no warranties, express or implies, as to the accuracy and reliability of Third-Party Content.

This content may contain helpful tips, explanation and advice. Your use of this information is voluntary and may not be effective in every circumstance. Amica encourages you to use good judgement and put safety first.

For more information on our editorial process and content standard, take a look at our editorial guidelines.

 

AMIC-03-041924